Who Pays in Personal Injury Lawsuits?
In Ontario, personal injury compensation is usually paid by an insurance company, not by the person who caused the accident. Insurance coverage is designed to handle injury claims and settlements in most cases.
Common Myth: The Defendant Pays Out of Pocket
A common misconception about personal injury claims is that the person being sued (the defendant) must personally pay compensation to the injured person. This mistake belief often makes people hesitant to pursue a claim because they worry about financially harming another individual.
In reality, almost all personal injury lawsuits are defended and paid by insurance companies. Insurance systems exist to provide financial protection when accidents and injuries occur. This enables injured individuals to recover compensation without requiring defendants to pay personally.
How Insurance Pays Injury Claims
In a typical personal injury lawsuit, the defendant’s insurance company will:
• Provide legal defence for the defendant
• Investigate the claim
• Negotiate settlement
• Pay any settlement or court judgment up to the policy limits
This means compensation usually comes from an insurance policy rather than from the defendant’s personal assets.
Car Accidents: Insurance Is Almost Always Available
In Ontario, automobile insurance is mandatory. When someone is injured in a motor vehicle accident and sues the at-fault driver, the at-fault driver’s automobile insurance company normally pays compensation and provides a legal defence.
Even in situations where the at-fault driver is uninsured or unidentified, injured people are still usually protected by insurance coverage through their own policy. Ontario policies include uninsured and unidentified motorist coverage, which allows an injured person’s own insurer to step into the role of the at-fault driver’s insurer.
In the extremely rare situation where no insurance coverage applies at all, claims may be made through the Motor Vehicle Accident Claims Fund, a public fund designed to compensate victims of uninsured or unidentified drivers.
For this reason, in car accident cases there is almost always an insurance source available to pay compensation.
Other Common Examples of Who Pays Compensation
Different types of accidents involve different types of insurance coverage.
The property owner’s liability insurance, such as homeowner’s or commercial insurance, typically pays compensation.
Accidents involving businesses
A business’s commercial liability insurance normally responds to injury claims arising from unsafe conditions or negligence.
When Might an Individual Pay Personally?
Although very rare, there are situations where a defendant could be personally responsible for paying compensation, including:
• When no insurance coverage exists at all
• When insurance coverage limits are exceeded by the value of the case
• In cases involving intentional or criminal conduct
These situations are the exception rather than the rule in Ontario personal injury cases.
Why Insurance Exists in Injury Claims
Insurance systems are designed to act as a financial safety net. They ensure that injured people can receive compensation for medical expenses, income loss, and long-term care without creating financial ruin for individuals who caused the accident.
Most people pay into insurance systems through automobile insurance, homeowner’s insurance, or business insurance for exactly this reason.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does the defendant usually pay compensation personally?
No. In most Ontario personal injury lawsuits, compensation is paid by an insurance company rather than by the defendant personally.
What happens if the defendant has no insurance?
If the defendant has no insurance, compensation may be limited and other legal options may need to be explored depending on the circumstances of the case.
Can an insurance company refuse to pay?
In some situations, an insurer may deny coverage due to policy breaches or exclusions. These disputes can be complex and often require legal interpretation.
Will suing someone financially ruin them?
In most cases, no. Because insurance pays compensation, personal injury lawsuits almost never result in defendants paying out of their own personal savings.
Closing Paragraph
Understanding who pays compensation in a personal injury lawsuit can help reduce fear and uncertainty about pursuing a claim. Because most injury claims are handled through insurance coverage, compensation is usually paid by an insurer rather than by the individual defendant.
Each situation is unique, and insurance coverage can vary depending on the type of accident and the policies involved.
You can explore more legal topics and answers to common questions in our Resources section.
Complete this form and someone from our office will contact you to arrange a free consultation. We work on a contingency basis, meaning you do not have to pay unless we resolve your claim successfully.
Contact Us
